John Logie's blog

core topics include rhetoric, internet studies, intellectual property, culture, politics.

 

WHY I BLOG

 

WHO IS LOGIE?

Assistant Professor, Department of
Rhetoric
, University of Minnesota.

Minneapolis resident.

Freelance crank.

Family Man.

 

 
Archives
<< current













 

BABY BLOGROLL

bIPlog

KAIROSNEWS

John Perry Barlow's BARLOWFRIENDZ

Joe Gratz's JOE GRATZ's BLOG

Mary Hodder's NAPSTERIZATION

Laurie Johnson's MY MEMEX

Lawrence Lessig's LESSIG BLOG

Declan McCullagh's POLITECH

Jim Oliver's JIM AND INTERNET

Clancy Ratliff's CULTURECAT

Derek Slater's A COPYFIGHTER'S MUSINGS

Tom Schaller, et alias' GADFLYER

Tom Tomorrow's THIS MODERN WORLD

Siva Vaidhyanathan's SIVACRACY.NET

Donna Wentworth's COPYFIGHT

 

 

 





























 
blogologie
 
Thursday, July 10, 2003  

Foxes in the Henhouse

The University of Delaware deserves a measure of credit for attempting to inject some levity and graphic appeal to its presentation of university standards on copyright and intellectual property. So, why is it that the smart people behind the yip-ee-ki-yay Western theme (and the cute repurposing of the Blue Hen mascot) are not also able to bring a reasonable measure of care and accuracy to the textual content on the site? Let's start with this obvious absurdity:
HONOR THE BRAND
Have you downloaded copyrighted files from the Internet?

You don't rustle cattle with someone else's brand, and, likewise, you don't use material that bears the Circle C (©) brand without first gettin' permission. If you do, it's stealin'--plain and simple.

Ummm . . . no. NOT plain and simple. There are MANY circumstances where it is both reasonable and ethical to use material with someone else's "brand." For starters, fair use ain't stealin', pardners. In fact, it's the part of the law that allows me to copy the above-cited words from your site and critique them, without fear of having my criticism smashed by means of a copyright-based economic hammer.


Even more disheartening is the list of "Copyright Resources" that awards slots #1 and #2 in a non-alphabetical listing to . . .


The RIAA and the MPAA!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

On this model, the Delaware student services office could offer a list of "Renter's Resources" with the first two listings being produced by landlord associations! I am astonished that this obviously biased presentation of copyright made it through the university's institutional hoops. And I'm concerned that "resources" like these might supplant good work like The University of Texas System's Crash Course in Copyright.




2:24 PM

 

 
This page is powered by Blogger. Creative Commons License